For brook trout, nothing beats a Humpy in mind opinion. I love them. I typically fish a very small mountain stream for brook trout. By small, I mean if this stream is 6 feet wide, I would be shocked. I have been fishing it for almost 20 years now and believe I know it like the back of my hand. I throw Humpies in sizes 14 and 16 in red, green, yellow, black, and orange. I have gotten some chartreuse ones but haven't used them yet. For the most part, red and yellow seem to be the best colors.
Damn I am getting some serious cabin fever now!